Monday, April 16, 2012

Another Book Review

HomeHome by Marilynne Robinson
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

This book, a companion piece to Gilead, written in the equally eloquent and poetic style of Robinson's previous book, captured my heart with the complexity of the themes developed in the telling of a story of a prodigal who comes home filled with much trepidation and perhaps a bit of hope.

While I loved this book, I loved Gilead more.  If one has read Gilead, and they should before they read this book, they will find that this book tells of Jack Boughton's experience while he was at home in Gilead after a long absence.

Many times, I found myself weeping as I read this book.  I wept because Jack felt he never had really been a part of the family.  I wept because Jack hurt so much inside that he could not accept himself or the way he had lived his life.  I wept because his family's love, a love that was deep and long lasting,  was not enough to hold keep him anchored in life.

I  admired Jack's honest questioning of life, and faith, and of grace.  I also admired his gentle nature.  His sensitive nature had been hardened and broken by life, and yet he remained at his core honest and sensitive despite his behavior that others interpreted as being dishonest and reprobate.  He found his solace in alcohol until it became the thing that also was destroying him and holding him in its grip.  He is a complex character.  One to study.  One to try and understand.  One in need of a grace which he found difficult to accept though he seemed to offer it to others at times.

The story, told through the third person voice of Jack's sister, Glory, lacked the dynamic first person voice used by Pastor Ames to tell the story of Gilead.  At times, I wished Jack were telling his own story, but then I realized the reader probably would have missed the complexity of Jack's character if he had told his own story.  Glory tried to make sense of Jack and his life and his behavior while he helped her make sense of her own life.

The themes of redemption, of grace, of loss, and of familial ties are all found in this amazing book.  Jack's father, Reverend Robert Boughton, is broken by age, arthritis, and a heart that has been heavy for much of his life for his prodigal son.

He has always taught and preached on grace, yet I thought he was really unable to accept Jack for who he really was, and was unable to extend a full measure of grace to Jack.  His treatment of Jack illustrates the complexity of praying for a prodigal while also accepting and understanding the prodigal who comes home.  It seemed it was almost impossible for the father to actually connect to Jack for who he was and for what he wanted most in life because of the father's inability to stop projecting his own interpretation to Jack's behavior and expectations onto Jack.  Reverend Boughton seems to be stuck in legalism at times, and his religion could almost be seen more as one of tradition and culture than as a belief system that is an exercise in faith based on grace.

Jack, of course, did not make it easy for his father to connect either.  There was a lifetime of misunderstanding and judgement that I felt never really was fully resolved by the father and the son.  Honesty had never been their style of relating.

Pastor Ames does not figure much in this story, but I still have the picture of him as Jack's true papa, the one who in the end was able to understand Jack and extend forgiveness and grace towards him.  Glory also extends understanding and grace towards Jack.  She seems to represent the true "glory" of the family who ministers to the prodigal while the others wish to rescue him or cause him to right his life to conform to the vision of what they want for him out of life.

Jack is an honest seeker.  One wonders if his experience at home will transform him when he leaves, or if he will continue to live a shattered life.

View all my reviews


  1. Good review, Sally... Sounds like a good book although it may not be as good as Gilead.

    I don't take time these days to do much reading --but if I did, I'd love a book like this one you reviewed.

    How are you feeling? Better I hope.

  2. I enjoyed this book tremendously, was deeply moved by it. While the story concentrates on Jack, we see Gloria's dilemma, her flaws, how she also disappointed her father. This tension is there all along, and makes the narrative so richly layered!
    A treasure, for sure.

  3. Very interesting review that makes me want to seek out Gilead first. Thanks for the great review.

  4. Good to see you back. Your comments about your husbands respone to replacement surgery are right on. For my love of the outdoor life and impending retirement the though of being unable to walk five minutes without great pain was too much. A new knee now allows me to go all day hiking, flyfishing and even mall shopping with my spouse...:
    Your book review reminded me to rethink my conclusion several decades ago that American fiction overall had declined to the point that reading much of it was a total waste of time. I though the new history and biography writing both actual and fictional had progressed to the point where it had become the best American writing. I still think that it true but I'm slowly edging away from that dogmatic view having read some really good fiction in recent. Your positive review and most importantly the reasons for it give me reason to think I'm on the right track. Thanks....

  5. Uh-oh. My comment didn't go through. I wanted to thank you for the comprehensive review. One more try, then I'll give up.

  6. I haven't read either of these but you make them sound well worth locating when I am ready for some serious reading. It seems like lately I have been choosing more light, quick reads.
    Thanks for the great review.

  7. I love to read and these sound like excellent choices. Thank you!

  8. Hi Sally. What a fantastic review, and you certainly seemed to have enjoyed this book tremendously. It is certainly going on my "To Read" List. Thanks for the recommendation.

  9. Sally, I didn't remember reading this book until I read your review! I also liked Gilead better, but Marilynne Robinson crafts wonderful complex stories. I liked both books. PS Mary and I are staying at Desert Pearl in May - thanks for your suggestion.

  10. Thanks for the thorough review. It will add an extra layer as I read, absorb and have an internal conversation about how my impressions align or differ from yours.

  11. Thanks for this great review, Sally. This sounds like a very relevant story with meaningful themes for today. I've been thinking about reading "Gilead," and I'll be sure to read that one first.

  12. There is so much information here that I feel I know the book already and no longer need to read it.
    You obviously love and admire the writer.

  13. I shall have to check out both Gilead and Home so I can compare myself. Sounds like I'll like 'em both!!!

    A very well written review sweetie!

    God bless and have a fantastic weekend sweetie!!! :O)

  14. I haven't come across these books but will look out for them. I suppose it would be best to start with Gilead.

    I'm sorry that I missed your last post but I have just caught up and commented. I admire your strength.
    Maggie X

    Nuts in May


Thank you for visiting my blog. I love reading your comments. Comments are moderated by the author of this blog. It may take a short delay for your comment to be published. No anonymous comments are published, nor are comments that are offensive to myself or other readers.